Massapequa Paid More for Mask Lawsuit Than Previously Reported

Massapequa paid more for their dismissed Mask Mandate Lawsuit than previously reported.

In November 2021, Newsday reported a cost to Massapequa taxpayers of $71,233.65 — the Hamburger Maxson bills for the firm's work in August and September, plus Guercio & Guercio's bill. The firm billed the district another $19,172.18 after that, for work through December. Invoices obtained under FOIL put the true cost at $90,405.83.

The invoices obtained under FOIL were paid to outside counsel Hamburger, Maxson, Yaffe & Martingale and total $83,658.59. With Guercio & Guercio's $6,747.24, the total is $90,405.83.

The lawsuit was brought on September 10, 2021 by Massapequa and Locust Valley when they sued Governor Hochul and the State Department of Health in Albany, challenging the state's rule requiring masks in schools. It was the second voluntary lawsuit filed by the board while Kerry Wachter has been president. They have now filed seven.

The case was dismissed November 23, 2021 for lack of capacity and failure to prove harm. Judge Zwack said in his ruling

“...the petitioners do not have the capacity to sue." School districts, he wrote, "do not have the inherent power to sue the State itself."

He found no harm, either. The districts "have alleged no injury."

A separate lawsuit, unrelated to Massapequa's, filed by parents, was successful in Nassau County court. The Nassau ruling was stayed the day after it was issued. The appeal was never decided. Before it could be resolved, the case became moot when the Governor lifted the mask mandate statewide on March 2, 2022.

Massapequa's case was dismissed for lack of capacity and standing, and it had no bearing on the state's mask repeal.

In the time since the district's mask mandate lawsuit, the school board's federal mascot lawsuit has been dismissed twice for lack of capacity and standing, and its regionalization lawsuit was dismissed for lack of standing. The Native American Guardians Association, the group that signed an agreement with the district in 2025 giving it permission to keep the Chiefs name, filed its own lawsuit over the state mascot ban. That lawsuit was dismissed for lack of standing.

With the corrected mask figure, the board's voluntary lawsuits have cost Massapequa taxpayers $436,227.62, with tens of thousands yet unaccounted for:

  • Mascot cases: $240,482

  • Bathroom policy: $87,902

  • Mask mandate: $90,406

  • Regionalization: $17,438

Two of those lawsuits are still active. The mascot appeals were argued in federal court on November 4, and a decision is expected in the coming months. The Title IX case is still being briefed — the board's next filing is due November 24, and the state's reply December 11. The state-court mascot case was dismissed on October 9.

Of the district's seven voluntary lawsuits, none has found success inside a courtroom.

Know someone who would want these updates? Tell them to sign up at stoptheboard.org/get-involved

Stop The Board is a group of Massapequa residents. The invoices behind this post are public records produced by the district under the Freedom of Information Law and are posted at stoptheboard.org/documents.

Next
Next

Thirty-Eight Minutes